“Start writing, no matter what. The water does not flow until the faucet is turned on.”
– Louis L’Amour
I’ve done NaNoWriMo at least fifteen times, maybe more—CAPTIVES was originally a NaNo project—and it feels weird not to be registered on the forums and faithfully reporting my daily word count on their site. I’m used to doing a writing push in November, and while that is still my plan, it won’t happen in connection with the NaNoWriMo organization.
Even though the only official prize for “winning” NaNoWriMo by finishing a 50, 000-word rough draft of a novel was some bragging rights and a website badge I always felt proud to be part of that bigger community. That changed a few months ago when the leaders of the nonprofit announced that the use of generative AI was completely okay with them, and accepted sponsorships by several such products. Furthermore, they called anyone who disagreed with them classist and ableist.
I’m not alone in having major issues with this, and right now, I’m not even aware of any events in my city. Certain tools, like Grammarly and other software that analyzes writing and makes suggestions, are already well-accepted as ways of brainstorming and polishing language. But generative AI, which can create whole works based on prompts, is something else. It’s one thing to take a trope or even a plot outline that you like and make it your own, but to me, the writer must put something of themselves into the work. I’m not interested in taking part in a prompt-writing competition, or in having my contributions to the organization’s forums, or even my manuscript itself, potentially used to train that kind of software. That’s not fair to any of us as writers, or creative people in general.
And then there are the allegations of grooming and predatory behaviour on their forums, which led the organization to shut them down. Although I’m glad they took these measures, I’m not clear on what they’re doing to get rid of the perpetrators and make things safe for young writers in particular.
Anyway, I hope the NaNoWriMo organization gets its policies sorted out and decides to treat all writers and creators with respect. In the meantime, I’ll be here, at my laptop, still writing.
